Theatrical Awards
- 2009 Recipient of Awards for Outstanding Production (The Secret Garden), Directing (Matthew Trombetta, Into the Woods), Ensemble Performance (Into the Woods), and Acting (Brice Corder, Sweet Charity; Angela Palazollo, The Cemetery Club; and Timothy Patrick, The Secret Garden) from the Central Ohio Theatre Roundtable
- Into the Woods voted a 'Best Production' of 2009 by Theatre Vault
- 2008 Recipient of the Award of Excellence for Directing - Choreography (Erika Twining - Thoroughly Modern Millie), and two Awards of Excellence for Acting (Morgan McCann and Dawn Farrell - Thoroughly Modern Millie) from the Central Ohio Theatre Roundtable
- 2007 Recipient of Awards for Outstanding Production (Ragtime) and Directing (Matthew Trombetta, Ragtime) from the Central Ohio Theatre Roundtable
- 2006 Recipient of the Award of Excellence for Outstanding Production (Children of Eden) from the Central Ohio Theatre Roundtable and the Central Ohio Theatre Critics’ Circle



